Tall Grass vs South Pointe: which 60564 subdivision fits your budget

You are weighing two neighborhoods in south Naperville and seeing a $130,000 gap between them. That gap is real, but it is not random. Tall Grass and South Pointe serve different buyers because they deliver different things. Understanding what each offers helps you figure out which one actually fits your life.
Tall Grass runs newer and costs more
Tall Grass has a median sale price of about $900,000, making it one of 60564's pricier subdivisions. The homes here tend to be newer custom builds with finished basements, a feature buyers seek when they want the work already done. The community also runs a school on site—Fry Elementary sits at 3204 Tall Grass Drive—which means families get assignment certainty and can skip the hunt for the right school district. Scullen Middle School is also a part of the subdivision. The pool, Clubhouse & tennis courts are an added feature with many social events lined up.
The subdivision sold 12 homes in August 2026, up 5.5% year over year. That volume is modest but steady, which means homes here do move. The price point selects for a specific buyer: someone with enough down payment saved to handle a $900K purchase, someone who values newer construction, or someone who will pay a premium for the school on site.
South Pointe sits on Route 59 and costs less
South Pointe sits along Route 59 south of 111th Street with a median sale price of about $770,000. That is $130,000 less than Tall Grass, a real difference in monthly payment. The homes here were built between 2002 and 2016, so they are not new but not aging either. A clubhouse, pool and tennis courts anchor the amenities, but there is no on-site school.
Route 59 access is what sets this subdivision apart. If you commute toward Chicago, I-88 or the Metra stations south on Route 59, this location cuts your drive time. That convenience carries value, and it explains why South Pointe attracts buyers who prioritize the commute over being the first owner of a brand new home.
Where the $130,000 gap actually comes from
The price difference is not one thing; it is a cluster of things.
- Newer homes cost more. Tall Grass was built mostly in the 2005s and 2020s. South Pointe peaked in the 2000s. Newer kitchens, roofs and systems mean less buyer risk and less money needed for rehab.
- School on site. Tall Grass families get assignment certainty. South Pointe families get District 202, but they land in a different school feeder. That matters to some buyers and not at all to others.
- Lot size and basement finish. Tall Grass leans toward custom homes with finished lower levels. South Pointe homes range from 3,179 to 6,470 square feet, so you get variety. A finished basement adds $50,000 to $100,000 in value here; it is less of a surprise in Tall Grass.
- Commute versus schools. South Pointe buyers want Route 59 access. Tall Grass buyers prioritize the school or the newer construction.
Neither gap is a defect. It is preference made visible in price.
How to know which one is for you
Ask yourself which constraint is tightest: your budget, your commute or your school assignment. If you are comfortable at $900K and want a newer home with a school nearby, Tall Grass is the clear fit. If $770K stretches your budget further or if a short drive to Route 59 matters more than a brand new roof, South Pointe opens up homes you might not otherwise see.
I run comps on any specific home you find, because subdivision medians hide real variation. One South Pointe home might sit on a quiet cul-de-sac backing to open space; another might face the main road. Same ZIP, same median, different appeal. Once you narrow to a subdivision, that is when we dial in the exact property that fits how you live.
What to check before you settle on either one
Before you commit to a subdivision, verify the small details that move value from street to street. School assignment changes by exact address, even within the same ZIP. Tax rate, HOA dues and county coverage (Will versus DuPage) all swing by location. Once you find a specific home, I pull the parcel data and confirm what you are actually buying into.
- School assignment by exact address through District 204
- HOA dues and what they cover—pool, clubhouse, common grounds
- Property tax rate for your specific township
- Whether you fall in Will County or DuPage County
- Any subdivision rules on fences, exterior changes or rentals if you might invest later
These details do not change the $900K-versus-$770K choice, but they do determine whether that choice is right for you.
Which neighborhood fits your actual life?
The right subdivision depends on your commute, your school priorities and what you need in a home. I work through these with every buyer and show you the math on medians, payments and carrying costs for each address. Let me know what matters most to you, and I'll narrow the search.